3 Comments

So what is storm water? Storm water is rain that is derailed from the hydrologic cycle by the built environment. This is my interpretation, not the definition you will find in the dictionary. Rain is supposed to be absorbed into the ground, or into streams or rivers, but instead flows down your gutters onto your driveway, into the street, the nearest catch basin and finally the nearest storm sewer. When rain becomes a problem to manage, it becomes storm water.

Six years ago, I added a second-story addition to my one-story, 1950's ranch house in Downers Grove, Ill. The addition included a 12x24-foot increase in the overall footprint of the house.  Schooled in my professional practice to think about how building new area decreases the ability for rain to be infiltrated back into the ground water in vegetated areas, I added a few elements to my house to offset my larger footprint. I added rain barrels, decreased the lawn area in favor of perennial gardens and added a green roof over my one-story attached garage.

The garage roof structure was replaced with 2x12s at 16-in. on center to carry the 5-inch deep system of under drainage, growing media and plants. The roof has a 45 percent slope and, at the time, was the steepest green roof in the Chicagoland area. Slotted aluminum angles 5 inches deep were placed mid-slope on each gable and at the edges of the roof to allow the system to drain freely to the gutters along each edge of the roof. The total area of the roof is approximately 525 square feet and acts like a giant living sponge absorbing much of the rain that falls onto it.  Once the system has absorbed as much rain as it can soak in, water begins to trickle into the gutters and slowly filters and releases excess water.  In contrast, the gutters receiving water from the shingled roof fill and rush with water in time with the rainfall. Long after the rain is done, the green roof continues to sing with the quiet cadence of trickling water, a song that can last for hours in the blazing sun.  

Green roofs offer many more benefits than the ability to filter and absorb storm water, however, I've never seen an economic case to justify their cost. While it's hard to put a blanket cost per square foot on a green roof because there are so many variables (flat, sloped, varying depths, structural capacity of existing building, roof membrane, etc.), I'd estimate that an average green roof cost approximately 25 dollars per square foot.

Yes, the life of your underlying roof membrane will be 2 to 3 times longer than if it was not protected by a vegetated protective layer, and yes, your cooling costs for the conditioned area of a building located under a green roof can be nearly neutralized.  But, if you try and force an economic justification for your green roof, I'm afraid you will be left wanting.  Consider looking out of your window to a garden instead onto asphalt shingles.  You might consider the value of your roof as I do - worth it.

Related Content

Reader Comments

Add a Comment

We welcome your thoughtful comments. All comments will display your real name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Or log in for complete access.

  • Clear
  • Post
  • David Gilmore
    about 18 months ago
    Green roofs can do much to benefit our world and our lives, and I strongly encourage everyone to explore ways to bring them into our cities. As a green roof professional, I am seeing a sharp decline in green roof costs, as more suppliers learn how to install them, and technological advances come into play.Too often green roofs are not used because of perceived high cost, when they may actually be much cheaper than expected. Certainly there are many green roofs sold for $25 per square foot, but simple systems, such as what a homeowner might put on a carport, may cost as little s $2 per square foot, and $5 per square foot can do much. Slopes clearly cost more.
    I believe there can be immediate and significant financial payback to building owners installing green roofs when rigid insulation is added to the bottom of the green roof profile, enhancing the energy saving potential of the green roof, and lowering energy costs for the building owner.
    David Gilmore, Green Roof Specialist, Etera, 360.661.2767 mobile
  • Lois Vitt Sale
    about 17 months ago
    Glenn Solsberry - In answer to your query - no, if the life of the roof is expected to be 10 years, when protected from UV degradation, roof life can be expected to double or triple.

    To your second question, the cooling action of the green roof is independent of rain...evapotranspiration - a part of photosynthesis, releases oxygen and moisture in the air and, in the process, induces a cooling layer over the roof. On Chicago's most famous green roof, the one atop its City Hall, temperature sensors were placed on the green roof as well as on an adjacent black roof and the temperature differential on the warmest Chicago summer days showed 60 to 70 degrees fahrenheit cooler on the green roof.
  • Lois Vitt Sale
    about 17 months ago
    David Gilmore - Any downward direction in the cost of green roofs is highly welcome because I agree that their first cost is most often the barrier to their proliferation. I'd put a green roof on every one of my projects if the budget would allow. While I know the larger the green roof, the lower the per square foot cost, I have never seen a green roof for as low as $2 per square foot. I have heard of a 170,000 square foot flat green roof for as little as $6 per square foot.
Products & Services

Affordable Housing

http://global1.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4512.png

4512/Affordable-Housing

Hydron Module Geothermal Systems

http://global1.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4813.png

4813/Hydron-Module-Geothermal-Systems

AMDECK Floor & Roof System

http://global2.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4277.png

4277/AMDECK-Floor-Roof-System

Verve Vacancy Sensor

http://global1.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4272.png

4272/Verve-Vacancy-Sensor

Residential Renovations

http://global2.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4510.png

4510/Residential-Renovations

Cooktop Glass

http://global1.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4791.png

4791/Cooktop-Glass

Puraflo® peat fiber biofilter

http://global2.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4383.png

4383/Puraflo-peat-fiber-biofilter

AMVIC ICF (Insulated Concrete Forms)

http://global1.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4276.png

4276/AMVIC-ICF-Insulated-Concrete-Forms

BioSTORM® Stormwater Treatment Systems

http://global1.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4593.png

4593/BioSTORM-Stormwater-Treatment-Systems

GeoComfort Geothermal Systems

http://global2.networldalliance.com/new/images/products/4811.png

4811/GeoComfort-Geothermal-Systems

Living Green - Real Case Studies

Latest posts by Lois Vitt Sale
Lois Vitt Sale
Lois is the Chief Sustainability Officer at Wight & Co., an integrated architecture, engineering and construction firm in Chicago. Lois will blog about her green experiences in the corporate world, as well as her personal accounts of living in a green home.
Request Information From Suppliers
Save time looking for suppliers. Complete this form to submit a Request for Information to our entire network of partners.